+359 887 407 840 office@escert.com Stara Zagora · Sofia · Plovdiv
BGEN

ResourcesAuditISO certification

Nonconformities in a certification audit: minor, major and what follows them

Major and minor nonconformities, corrective action and the certification decision

A nonconformity is a failure to meet a requirement, established by the auditor with objective evidence; under ISO/IEC 17021-1 it is major or minor depending on whether it affects the ability of the management system to achieve its intended results. What follows depends on the type: a major one must be resolved and verified before the certification decision, while a minor one is closed with a corrective action plan.

Euro Standard CertificationThe ESCERT team Published
Updated
6 minread
Auditor with a folder of documents inspecting equipment in a production hall

What is a nonconformity and who decides?

A nonconformity is a failure to meet a requirement. The requirement may come from the standard, from a law or regulation, from a customer contract or from the organization’s own documents - a policy, a procedure, an instruction. The auditor records it only when there is objective evidence, and describes it so that it is clear which requirement is not met and what the evidence is.

Audit findings are not only nonconformities. The auditor also notes observations - places where the requirement is met but at risk of no longer being met - and opportunities for improvement. They do not stop the certificate, but they are a useful list for the following year. The audit report contains all findings, and the organization receives a copy of it.

  • RequirementA clause of the standard, a legal provision or the organization’s own procedure - a nonconformity always refers to a specific requirement.
  • EvidenceA document, a record, an on-site observation or a conversation with an employee that the auditor has verified personally.
  • ObservationThe requirement is met, but weakly or unstably. A recommendation, not a nonconformity.
  • ReportEvery finding is described with the requirement, the evidence and the auditor’s assessment.

Major or minor nonconformity: what is the difference?

ISO/IEC 17021-1 - the standard that accredited certification bodies work to - divides nonconformities into two grades according to their impact on the management system.

Major nonconformity

  • Affects the ability of the system to achieve its intended results.
  • For example: a whole requirement of the standard is missing or not applied; a systematic breach of a legal obligation; no evidence that the process is under control.
  • Several minor nonconformities against the same requirement can also reveal a systemic problem and be graded as a major one.
  • Stops the issue of the certificate until resolution and verification.

Minor nonconformity

  • Does not affect the ability of the system to achieve its intended results.
  • For example: a single missing record, an outdated document, one untrained position, one overdue calibration.
  • Closed with a root-cause analysis and a corrective action plan.
  • Implementation is verified at the next surveillance audit.
Examples by standard
StandardUsually majorUsually minor
ISO 9001No management review or internal audit for the whole cycleOne product inspection record is missing
ISO 14001An activity without the required permit or without an evaluation of legal complianceOne waste stream without a current contract
ISO 45001No risk assessment for a whole process with hazardous activitiesA single missed safety briefing, documented afterwards
ISO/IEC 27001The Statement of Applicability does not match the risk assessmentOne unrevoked access right of a former employee

Grading the severity is up to the auditor and depends on the context: the same lapse may be minor in a trading company and major in a plant handling hazardous substances. What matters is whether the system keeps working despite the lapse.

What follows a major nonconformity?

A major nonconformity is not a refusal of the certificate but a halt in the process until the problem is solved. The certification body requires the organization to analyse the causes, describe the correction and the corrective action and submit evidence, and then verifies the result - through a document review or an additional on-site visit.

  1. 1Correction

    The immediate action that removes the nonconformity itself: the missing permit is obtained, the missed training is delivered, the uncontrolled process is stopped.

  2. 2Root-cause analysis

    Why did it happen - a missing procedure, resources, competence, control? The cause is rarely “human error”; it is usually a missing rule or check.

  3. 3Corrective action

    The change that prevents recurrence: a new procedure, a person responsible, a control point, a checking schedule. With a deadline and evidence of implementation.

  4. 4Verification by the certification body

    The auditor reviews the evidence or visits the organization again. Only after a positive verification does the audit team recommend certification.

For initial certification the standard also sets a time limit: if the certification body cannot verify the resolution of the major nonconformity within six months of the last day of Stage 2, another Stage 2 audit is conducted before certification can be recommended. At a surveillance audit an unresolved major nonconformity leads to suspension of the certificate already issued.

What follows a minor nonconformity?

A minor nonconformity does not stop the certificate. The organization submits a root-cause analysis and a corrective action plan within the time set by the certification body, and the auditor accepts the plan if it is adequate. Implementation itself is verified at the next surveillance audit. If by then the action has not been implemented or the problem has recurred, the nonconformity is upgraded to major.

Acceptable response

  • A specific cause related to the process, not to a person.
  • An action that changes the rule or the control, not just fixes the case.
  • A person responsible, a deadline and evidence the auditor can verify.

Unacceptable response

  • “The employee was instructed” with no change to the process.
  • “The document was updated” with no reason why it was out of date.
  • A plan without a deadline, a person responsible or evidence.

The most common mistakes when responding to nonconformities

  • Symptom fixed, cause alive

    The missing record is filled in, but the rule that should have created it stays unchanged - at the next audit the record is missing again.

  • Argument instead of analysis

    The organization disputes the finding instead of checking the requirement. If there are grounds, they are presented with evidence as early as the closing meeting.

  • Missed deadline

    The plan is good, but the evidence arrives after the certification body’s deadline - the process stops, and for initial certification a new Stage 2 may be required.

The body that certifies you cannot tell you how to resolve the nonconformity - that would be consultancy, which ISO/IEC 17021-1 prohibits for the sake of impartiality. It verifies whether your solution works.

How to have fewer nonconformities at the audit?

Most nonconformities can be seen in advance. Stage 1 of the certification audit exists for exactly this: the auditor reviews the documentation and readiness and points out the areas that could become nonconformities at Stage 2. The organization is given time to resolve them between the two stages.

  • Carry out a full internal audit with trained auditors and treat the findings as real nonconformities.
  • Hold a management review with all the inputs required by the standard and with minutes recording the decisions.
  • Review the legal requirements and permits - the most serious nonconformities are found there.
  • Check whether the records your procedures promise are really being created.
  • Close old nonconformities with a root-cause analysis, not just a correction.

Specific examples by clause are in the article ISO 14001 audit: the 10 most common nonconformities, and the whole path from enquiry to certificate is in Certification process.

Accredited ISO certificationQuote within two hours during business hoursGet a quote

Questions about audit nonconformities

Is the certificate refused in the event of a major nonconformity?

Not immediately. A major nonconformity halts the process: the organization analyses the cause, resolves the nonconformity and submits evidence, and the certification body verifies it. The certificate is issued after a positive verification. For initial certification, if verification is not possible within six months of Stage 2, a new Stage 2 is conducted.

How many minor nonconformities are acceptable in an audit?

The standard does not set a number. Minor nonconformities are closed with a corrective action plan and do not stop the certificate, but several minor ones against the same requirement may reveal a systemic problem and be graded as a major nonconformity.

What is the difference between a correction and a corrective action?

A correction removes the nonconformity itself - for example it fills in the missing record. A corrective action removes the cause so that it does not recur - for example it introduces a rule on who creates the record and when. The auditor expects both.

Can the auditor tell me how to resolve the nonconformity?

No. The certification body cannot provide consultancy to the organization it audits - an impartiality requirement under ISO/IEC 17021-1. The auditor identifies the requirement and the evidence, while the solution is up to the organization or an independent consultant.

What happens with a nonconformity found at a surveillance audit?

The same rules: a major one must be resolved and verified within the time set by the certification body, otherwise the certificate may be suspended; a minor one is closed with a plan and verified at the next audit.

Free preliminary assessment and quote

An audit that shows, not punishes

Describe your activity, sites and number of employees - you will receive a quote with the scope, the audit duration and the price with all costs included. Certificate from CERTIND S.A., accredited by RENAR.